https://www.vocera.com/blog/elevating-humanity-technology-decisions Skip to main content
  • Careers
  • 1.888.986.2372
  • United States
    • United States
    • United Kingdom
    • Australia
    • New Zealand
    • Middle East
    • Canada
  • search
  • Customer Support
Logo Vocera
Menu
MenuMenuMenu
1.888.986.2372 Close Menu
  • About Vocera
    • Careers
    • Our Mission
    • Newsroom
    • COVID-19
    • Year Of The Nurse
    • Virtual Events
  • Products
    • V5000 Smartbadge
      V5000
      Smartbadge
    • B3000N Badge
      B3000N
      Badge
    • Vocera Products
      Compare
      Vocera Products
    • Vocera Accessories
      Vocera
      Accessories
    • Vocera Platform
      Vocera
      Platform
    Vocera Enterprise Platform
    • Engage Intelligent Workflow
    • Analytics
    Compare Communication Devices
    • Minibadge
    • Smartbadge
    • Badge
    • Smartphones
    Mobile Applications
    • Vocera Edge
    • Vina
    • Collaboration Suite
    Patient and Family Engagement
    • Ease Application
    • Rounds
    • Care Calls
  • Solutions
    • Family Communication
    • Staff Safety
    • Secure Text Messaging
    • Alarm Management
    • Integrations
    • Pager Replacement
    • COVID-19
  • Services
    • Customer Technical Support
    • Access Technical Support Portal (customers with active support contracts).

    • Professional Services
    • Experts to help with workflow enhancements and solution deployment.

    • Vocera University
    • Accelerate proficiency and performance with our customized courseware.

    • Accessories and E-Store
    • Order batteries, chargers, specially-designed lanyards and clips, headsets and more.

  • Industries
    • Healthcare
    • Veterans' Affairs Healthcare
    • Department of Defense Healthcare
    • Long-Term Care
    • Hospitality
    • Retail
    • Veterinary Care
    • Education
    • Energy
  • Resources
    • Brochures
    • Case Studies
    • Data Sheets
    • Guides
    • Technical Documentation
    • Solution Briefs
    • Videos
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • Blog
    • Podcast
  • contact us
  • support portal
  • contact us
  • United States
    • United States
    • United Kingdom
    • Australia
    • New Zealand
  • search
Vocera Logo

525 Race Street San Jose, CA 95126 United States (888)-9VOCERA

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Elevating Humanity in Technology Decisions
    • All Topics
    • Enabling Safety and Quality Care
    • Saving Steps and Saving Time
    • Transforming
      the Experience
    • Enhancing Care
      with Technology

    Elevating Humanity in Technology Decisions

    • by Liz Boehm
      Executive Strategist, Human-Centered Research

    Topics Covered:

    • Enhancing Care with Technology

    Share:

    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • Linkedin
    • print
    July, 2019
    Elevating Humanity in Technology Decisions
    Elevating Humanity in Technology Decisions

    Technology gets a bad rap in healthcare. A lot of that is earned. 

    Doctors in ambulatory care spend roughly two hours on EHR and desk work for every hour of patient care – and that’s before they spend another one-to-two hours at home.i Nurses working in an inpatient hospital spend about a third of their time using technology.ii

    When technology adds complexity to the care environment, it contributes to an increase in clinicians’ risk for cognitive overload and, ultimately, burnout.iii

    At Vocera, we believe strongly in the potential for technology to unleash human potential, provided  that leaders who select and implement technology intentionally select for solutions that promise a positive human impact.iv

    Positive “human impact” is the extent to which a technology enhances human connection and compassion, expands human capacity, improves communication, relieves cognitive burden, and allows team members to connect to purpose.

    Healthcare Technology Selection and Implementation Processes Have a Humanity Deficit

    To find out whether, when, and how healthcare executives consider human impact when choosing and implementing new technologies, we conducted an online survey of 45 executives responsible for influencing technology decisions. The survey was conducted during February and March of 2019.

    Fewer than one in five of our survey respondents said their organization has a set of human-centered criteria for assessing and implementing technology.

    When we asked respondents how critical factors such as price, integration, and ease of use are in their organizations’ technology selection process, price and technical factors ranked well above human impact factors (see Figure 1). For example, less than a third indicated that solutions that enable clinicians to spend time caring for patients are critical, while more than half said technical fit is a must-have.

    Healthcare organizations are making some up-front investments in fostering successful technology deployments (see Figure 2). Our respondents told us that user training and hands-on technical support are nearly universal, and almost two-thirds of organizations ‘always’ or ‘usually’ create opportunities for localization or customization of technology-based solutions. 

    Yet, many organizations are still missing key opportunities to create dialog with and support end-users during the implementation phase:

    • Only 37% always or usually provide change management support.
    • Only 32% always or usually involve frontline teams in defining the success metrics for tech solutions.
    • Only 21% always or usually solicit patient and family perspectives.

    When we delved into which specific aspects of human impact healthcare technology decision makers pay attention to most, respondents indicated that only three elements are usually or always on their priority list at least 50% of the time (see Figure 3): 

    • Helping teams manage complex information
    • Supporting a safe working environment
    • Helping with resource allocation

    Factors such as whether solutions help involve patients in their own care or boost team morale are always or usually considered by less than a quarter of respondents. Given the current challenge with excessive administrative tasks, burnout, and lack of time for clinicians to connect meaningfully with patients, it will be ever more critical for technology decision makers to consider the human impact when selecting and implementing technology.

    Humanity Needs a Seat at the Technology Table

    Forward-thinking healthcare executives recognize that to be sustainable and support healthcare’s healing mission, technology needs to be integrated with people and processes in a way that enhances humanity. To advance that purpose, we convened twenty senior healthcare executives at NewYork-Presbyterian to co-create a human-centered framework for technology selection and deployment that aligns technical requirements with human impact considerations to create sustainable value.  

    This framework puts human impact criteria on par with cost and technical priorities and broadens how vendors and healthcare leaders think about ‘value.’ We also outline human-centered practices for governance, change management, support, and measurement for technology implementation in the clinical environment.

    As one survey participant said, “Technology should be the tail and not the dog. It should enable, empower, and augment successful care and caring.”

    Looking forward, it is our shared vision that technology transcend technical requirements to expand human capacity and connection across healthcare. For now, we will continue to validate and refine the frameworks by partnering with leaders from across our Experience Innovation Network membership who will incorporate these ideas into their existing technology planning and selection processes. 

     

    If your organization is interested in getting involved with our Humanity and Technology Council or learning more about our frameworks, please reach out to RJ Salus, Executive Director, Experience Innovation Network at rjsalus@vocera.com.

    ______________

    i Sinsky C, Colligan L, Li L, Prgomet M, Reynolds S, Goeders L, et al. Allocation of Physician Time in Ambulatory Practice: A Time and Motion Study in 4 Specialties. Ann Intern Med. [Epub ahead of print 6 September 2016]165:753–760. doi: 10.7326/M16-0961

    ii A Higgins, Linda W., Shovel, Judith A., Bilderback, Andrew L., Lorenz, Holly L., Martin, Susan C., Rogers, Debra J., Minnier, Tamra E., Hospital Nurses' Work Activity in a Technology-Rich Environment: A Triangulated Quality Improvement Assessment, Journal of Nursing Care Quality 2017, doi: 10.1097/NCQ.0000000000000237

    iii https://www.vocera.com/blog/cognitive-overload-problem-clinicians-approaching-technology-differently-may-be-solution

    iv Patel, V. L., & Kannampallil, T. G. (2014). Human factors and health information technology: current challenges and future directions. Yearbook of medical informatics, 9(1), 58–66. doi:10.15265/IY-2014-0005

    Share:

    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • Linkedin
    • print

    Most Recent

    Recommended

    • A broad definition of healthcare workplace violence leads to better caregiver safety

    • To help retain nurses, fix communication: NASA TLX survey

    • A Framework for Achieving your Smart, Connected Hospital Vision

    • Healthcare System Administrators – Celebrating their Contributions to Optimizing Healthcare

    • Nurses Are Calling for Innovation. Let’s Listen.

    • Hospital Secure Messaging: 7 Lessons Learned

    • Three Tips for Reducing Sepsis Risk

    • Halifax Health: Better Communication for Better Patient Care

    Pagination

    • Current page 1
    • Page 2
    • Next page Next ›
    • Last page Last »

    Most Recent Related Stories

    nurse walking looking at smartphone device

    A Framework for Achieving your Smart, Connected Hospital Vis...

    nurses working, patient in bed vocera CNO report

    Nurses Are Calling for Innovation. Let’s Listen.

    male and female nurse looking at tablet

    Simplify Clinical Communication with Vocera Cloud-Based Solu...

    Stay Connected
    3030 Orchard Parkway
    San Jose Ca, 95134
    United States

    (888)-986-2372

    ABOUT US
    • Home
    • Year Of The Nurse
    • Empower Heroes
    • Customer Advocacy
    • Locations
    • Patient Privacy
    • Partners
    • Social and Environmental Responsibility
    • Supply Chain Transparency
    • Ethics Hotline
    Careers
    News & Events
    • Press Releases
    • News and Research
    • Events
    • Virtual Events
    • Gartner Reports
    Resource Center
    • Blog
    • Case Studies
    • Data Sheets
    • Guides
    • Podcast
    • Solution Briefs
    • Videos
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    PRESS RELEASES
    BLOGS
    PODCAST
     
    © Copyright 2023 Vocera Communications. All Rights Reserved.
    Privacy - Legal - Site Map